Well Friday comes around pretty quickly, just wish the weekend could slow down sometimes. But anyway here are my tips for round 19.
Carlton vs Geelong (MCG) Friday night.
Friday night games for me are always interesting, I have had an interesting mix of hit and misses when it comes to the tipping side of things. I think that tonights game has a lot of potential to be a close game. You look at the players that are both in and out for both clubs and who has the potential to take the game on. You just don't know with these two sides. To me Carlton have lifted this year whilst Geelong are not quite the side that they have been the last two years. Having said that previous form means didly squat, it's what happens on the day that counts. The midfield battle is going to be a beauty, it's going to be won there. And the stars that are in for both teams, ah my mouth is watering at the prospect! After careful consideration I still think the Cats will win by 12 points but a good arm wrestle.
Western Bulldogs vs West Coast (Etihad) Saturday.
This is the one I call the battle of the West's (ha ha geddit?). Western Bulldogs had a good but a not quite there win against Fremantle and would be looking at getting some much needed momentum leading into the finals. On the otherhand West Coast who people were acussing of tanking are coming off a much needed win and will be looking at gaining some confidence leading into 2010. In this case though the home town advantage would give the Dogs the edge and they will win by 23 points.
Hawthorn vs St Kilda (Aurora Stadium) Saturday.
Hmm I have been looking forward to this game for weeks, I really have. St Kilda who are undefeated have some big names missing from their lineup the likes of Riewoldt, Hayes, Montagna, Baker and Goddard which will depleat their lineup. The Hawks on the otherhand will have some handy inclusions. Hawthorn, they haven't been playing the best and St Kilda are on the top of the ladder. Who do you go for? Believe you me this was one of the toughest games of the round to pick and it almost gave me a headache before I said to myself "Common girlie just pick a side" and I'm hoping I made the right decision, but really is there anyway of knowing, that is unless you can see into the future! After much deliberating and careful consideration I have decided to pick a depleated St Kilda side based upon form to win by 2 points. They will do enough to win and even if they don't it would be better for them then if they go through the year with at least one loss.
Essendon vs Brisbane (MCG) Saturday night.
Yet another hard choice. Brisbane welcome back Bradshaw and others while Essendon have some big names out. Essendon had a big chance to win last week while Brisbane do need to win to keep in contention with the top four. The matchups just like in all games are going to be crutial and it would be interesting to see who goes to Brown and Bradshaw and if these two are contained then Essendon could be in for a big showing. But a lot of people are confident in the fact that Brisbane have the upper hand, I don't necessarily think so. I believe that the backs up against the wall Essendon will come out and have the will to win this game and win by 7 points.
Adelaide vs Collingwood (AAMI Stadium) Saturday Night.
Man another had game to pick. Collingwood have a really good record at AAMI Stadium against Adelaide including one last September. Adelaide are one of the in form sides of the year and came within a wisker of the Cats last week and could beat a lot of sides with persistence. Collingwood too have had a good year. When you do look at the ins and outs things are matched up well. To me though Adelaide will be fired up to win this game after just losing last week and will win by 18 points.
North Melbourne vs Melbourne (Etihad Stadium) Sunday.
Hmm another intesting game. North's kicking kicked them out of the game against the Blues last Friday Night. On the otherhand Melbourne should have won against Richmond in a game everyone (but me) has said that Melbourne tanked. If this game was at the G then I would say that Melbourne had a really good chance of winning the game, however North play Etihad better and will win by 33 points.
Richmond vs Sydney (MCG) Sunday.
This game is Michael O'Lauchlin's 300th Game. What a champion of the game! His service to the game is unbelieveable and he has won a premiership which a lot of champions of the game miss out on. What a career! Is that going to be enough to spur the Swans onward to victory? Or will the Richmond winning (yes I did say winning) ways continue? Sydney's interstate record of late hasn't been the best that is a major question in itself but another question is whether Richmond will sustain this momentum. This will be a good game I reckon. I am going to pick the Swans to win for Micky O by 11 points.
Fremantle vs Port Adelaide (Subiaco) Sunday.
You never know which way this game's going to go. Which teams will come out to play for both clubs? A good Fremantle will beat anyone at home, a bad one will let any side run all over them. Port on the otherhand had a much needed win against Hawthorn and like Freo can be really bad as well as really good. TO me though, Port will win this game by 8 points.
Well that's my tips for the week. Let's see how I go.
Catch ya!
Friday, August 7, 2009
Thursday, August 6, 2009
Thought of the week
Actually it is three thoughts really.
First of all. I am sick to death of the whole Tanking issue! Get over it people! People are going to argue with me til they're black and blue but I am so sure that Melbourne did not tank on the weekend! I personally think they are at the moment naturally bad! Sorry Melbourne fans but they are! There is a big difference between a natural bad performance and tanking. The way that Melbourne played on the weekend was not bad (maybe from Richmond yes!) and that wasn't the problem, but the couple of mistakes that was hi lighted meant that of course they had to be tanking. If that's the case then everyone must be tanking! Please people come on!
Second of all. I would like to hi light a couple of lucky results. With regards to the Geelong and Adelaide game, that was a good tight contest and maybe the right result happened. But there was a couple of games that I would have to say were a bit dodgy. The Sydney and St Kilda game was a fantastic game and I did mention that I will have to see the footage regarding Leigh Montagna. Well I did see it and I would have to agree with others that St Kilda were lucky not to get a free kick against them. Would it in fact influence the game? Maybe maybe not but it would have given Sydney a chance to win the game, but most likely it would have been a drawn game and therefore the Saints would still be undefeated but wouldn't have won all the games like they have now. To me at least a free kick should have been paid and who knows what the rest of the game would have done, to me the Saints were lucky really. The Second game was the game that is in question is the Melbourne and Richmond game. With four seconds to go the ball wasn't even kicked to Jordan McMahon and to me the ball was in the air when the siren went. The umpire paid it and well the rest was history. Really Melbourne should have won, and what about if they had? All I can say is that we won't be talking about the whole tanking issue won't we?!
Just getting onto the tanking issue. To me there is a way in which to stamp this out, stop the priority pick rule as it stands. The AFL need to look at a different system in order to ensure that tanking doesn't become an issue. To me you need to reward teams that win, and I'm not talking about up the top of the ladder but you need to encourage teams on the bottom of the ladder to win. This is what I think:
1. You can put in a draft like the one in the NBA. The bottom teams go into a lottery after the bottom three teams get picks 1,2, and 3. The rest of the picks are determined by a lottery. I have toyed with this idea while it's ok, it would need a bit of work for it to be successfull.
2. Scrap Priority picks in general and whatever order you finish on the ladder determines your draft picks, much more fair way of doing things.
3. If there are going to be priority picks make it to reward teams. For one thing if a team finishes last, second and third last then they have got to win more games the next year than the previous year (regardless of their position) to get a priority pick. Yes this will have it's downfall especially if teams deliberately have a bad year then go all out the following year. To me that will work only if teams are down towards the bottom end of the ladder for more than one year in a row. To me you need to reward winning not losing.
What do you think? Email me carefactor0@live.com.au.
Catch ya!
First of all. I am sick to death of the whole Tanking issue! Get over it people! People are going to argue with me til they're black and blue but I am so sure that Melbourne did not tank on the weekend! I personally think they are at the moment naturally bad! Sorry Melbourne fans but they are! There is a big difference between a natural bad performance and tanking. The way that Melbourne played on the weekend was not bad (maybe from Richmond yes!) and that wasn't the problem, but the couple of mistakes that was hi lighted meant that of course they had to be tanking. If that's the case then everyone must be tanking! Please people come on!
Second of all. I would like to hi light a couple of lucky results. With regards to the Geelong and Adelaide game, that was a good tight contest and maybe the right result happened. But there was a couple of games that I would have to say were a bit dodgy. The Sydney and St Kilda game was a fantastic game and I did mention that I will have to see the footage regarding Leigh Montagna. Well I did see it and I would have to agree with others that St Kilda were lucky not to get a free kick against them. Would it in fact influence the game? Maybe maybe not but it would have given Sydney a chance to win the game, but most likely it would have been a drawn game and therefore the Saints would still be undefeated but wouldn't have won all the games like they have now. To me at least a free kick should have been paid and who knows what the rest of the game would have done, to me the Saints were lucky really. The Second game was the game that is in question is the Melbourne and Richmond game. With four seconds to go the ball wasn't even kicked to Jordan McMahon and to me the ball was in the air when the siren went. The umpire paid it and well the rest was history. Really Melbourne should have won, and what about if they had? All I can say is that we won't be talking about the whole tanking issue won't we?!
Just getting onto the tanking issue. To me there is a way in which to stamp this out, stop the priority pick rule as it stands. The AFL need to look at a different system in order to ensure that tanking doesn't become an issue. To me you need to reward teams that win, and I'm not talking about up the top of the ladder but you need to encourage teams on the bottom of the ladder to win. This is what I think:
1. You can put in a draft like the one in the NBA. The bottom teams go into a lottery after the bottom three teams get picks 1,2, and 3. The rest of the picks are determined by a lottery. I have toyed with this idea while it's ok, it would need a bit of work for it to be successfull.
2. Scrap Priority picks in general and whatever order you finish on the ladder determines your draft picks, much more fair way of doing things.
3. If there are going to be priority picks make it to reward teams. For one thing if a team finishes last, second and third last then they have got to win more games the next year than the previous year (regardless of their position) to get a priority pick. Yes this will have it's downfall especially if teams deliberately have a bad year then go all out the following year. To me that will work only if teams are down towards the bottom end of the ladder for more than one year in a row. To me you need to reward winning not losing.
What do you think? Email me carefactor0@live.com.au.
Catch ya!
Tuesday, August 4, 2009
After the weekend.
Round 18 has been and gone this year has gone so quickly!
Friday night saw North Melbourne host Carlton at Etihad Stadium in what was Adam Simpson's last game for the Roos. The pressure of this game was up and it wasn't really a high scoring game which to be honest I kind of expected. Carlton went on to win by 10 points. Really if North had kicked straight in that last quarter then they would have had a convincing win over the Blues but because of that the result went the other way. It wasn't the way that Adam Simpson should have been sent off but really I thought it was a fantastic effort by him to get up for the game considering he tore his calf in the last training before the game. What a champion of the game!
To Saturday. Western Bulldogs hosted Fremantle at Etihad Stadium and to be honest I thought that the Dogs were going to beat Freo in a convincing style (in otherwords thump em!) but to the Dockers credit they held off it being an embarrassing result as it could have been, the Dogs winning by 31 points. Brad Johnson broke the games record for the Dogs being 342 and it was a nice way of him being sent off for that! Although it was a bitter sweet day for Lindsay Gilbee who's father passed away the night before from Luekemia and he still played and did quite well considering what he had to go through. My respect for the man went up bigtime for what he had to go through. They had a win for him too!! Well done.
In the other game. Geelong hosted Adelaide at Skilled Stadium. This was one of three thrillers in the round. Geelong started well but Adelaide came back and in the last quarter got in front. But it was a Geelong side lead by Paul Chapman (who I reckon should be next captain) who kicked 6 goals straight held on to win by 2 points. I have to give full credit to Adelaide they are my pick of the interstate clubs to go far in September. It makes it two close games in two weeks and three this year for the Cats. No more please!
To Saturday Night. Sydney hosted St Kilda at the SCG. This to me was the game of the round. It was close all the way through. Sydney kept on coming at the Saints and got in front from an awesome tap from Adam Goodes to Jesse White who kicked a goal and there was a possibility that there could have been an upset on the cards. But the persistence from the Saints proved why they are the best at the moment and they got back equal before a quick kick and point from Leigh Montagna won them the game. Now I have found out (I haven't yet seen the replay) that aparantly Leigh pushed Keiran Jack to the ground before kicking the point and therefore should have been a free kick. I will have to watch the footage again. I will let you know what I think.
At the MCG this saw Collingwood host Brisbane in Simon Blacks 250th Game. At the start of the game the Lions came out with the hunger to win and Brown kicking goals left right and centre and you thought that maybe there could have been an upset. But it wasnt to be the Pies coming out and playing good football to win by 40 points.
To Sunday. And Melbourne hosted Richmond at the MCG. From start to finish this was right up there with the Sydney/St Kilda game as game of the round. Both teams had time in front and Richmond got out to a bit of a lead in the fourth quarter and I thought that that was the game. But Melbourne came back and got in front from a Ricky Pettard goal. Then a new Tiger attitude came and a kick to Jordan McMahon with 4 seconds to go (well actually it was in the air when the siren went, but the ump paid the mark and that's that) meant that he had to kick it in order for Richmond to win. And he did and boy did he need to do that! Still what a game and like Geelong Richond have played in two close games in a row!
To AAMI Stadium. And Port Adelaide hosted Hawthorn. This was kind of a see-sawing affair that eventually saw Port Adelaide to go out to a lead and stay there winning by 18 points. Well. What's going to happen to Hawthorn? They are now 10th on the ladder with four rounds to go! Can they make finals? Really they have to win all games for the rest of the year to give them a real chance. They have St Kilda at Aurora Stadium, then Adelaide at the MCG, Richmond at the MCG, and Essendon at the MCG. Now they could win all those games but I don't think that they can and may have to rely on others winning/losing in order for them to get in and believe you me they do not want to do that.
To the last game of the round that saw West Coast hosted Essendon at Subiaco. This was a game that a lot of people (including myself) thought that Essendon would win. But from the start West Coast controlled the game running away to win the game by 27 points. Obviously being sick of the tanking claims! Really I don't think clubs are tanking, maybe bad, but definately not tanking!
Catch ya!
Friday night saw North Melbourne host Carlton at Etihad Stadium in what was Adam Simpson's last game for the Roos. The pressure of this game was up and it wasn't really a high scoring game which to be honest I kind of expected. Carlton went on to win by 10 points. Really if North had kicked straight in that last quarter then they would have had a convincing win over the Blues but because of that the result went the other way. It wasn't the way that Adam Simpson should have been sent off but really I thought it was a fantastic effort by him to get up for the game considering he tore his calf in the last training before the game. What a champion of the game!
To Saturday. Western Bulldogs hosted Fremantle at Etihad Stadium and to be honest I thought that the Dogs were going to beat Freo in a convincing style (in otherwords thump em!) but to the Dockers credit they held off it being an embarrassing result as it could have been, the Dogs winning by 31 points. Brad Johnson broke the games record for the Dogs being 342 and it was a nice way of him being sent off for that! Although it was a bitter sweet day for Lindsay Gilbee who's father passed away the night before from Luekemia and he still played and did quite well considering what he had to go through. My respect for the man went up bigtime for what he had to go through. They had a win for him too!! Well done.
In the other game. Geelong hosted Adelaide at Skilled Stadium. This was one of three thrillers in the round. Geelong started well but Adelaide came back and in the last quarter got in front. But it was a Geelong side lead by Paul Chapman (who I reckon should be next captain) who kicked 6 goals straight held on to win by 2 points. I have to give full credit to Adelaide they are my pick of the interstate clubs to go far in September. It makes it two close games in two weeks and three this year for the Cats. No more please!
To Saturday Night. Sydney hosted St Kilda at the SCG. This to me was the game of the round. It was close all the way through. Sydney kept on coming at the Saints and got in front from an awesome tap from Adam Goodes to Jesse White who kicked a goal and there was a possibility that there could have been an upset on the cards. But the persistence from the Saints proved why they are the best at the moment and they got back equal before a quick kick and point from Leigh Montagna won them the game. Now I have found out (I haven't yet seen the replay) that aparantly Leigh pushed Keiran Jack to the ground before kicking the point and therefore should have been a free kick. I will have to watch the footage again. I will let you know what I think.
At the MCG this saw Collingwood host Brisbane in Simon Blacks 250th Game. At the start of the game the Lions came out with the hunger to win and Brown kicking goals left right and centre and you thought that maybe there could have been an upset. But it wasnt to be the Pies coming out and playing good football to win by 40 points.
To Sunday. And Melbourne hosted Richmond at the MCG. From start to finish this was right up there with the Sydney/St Kilda game as game of the round. Both teams had time in front and Richmond got out to a bit of a lead in the fourth quarter and I thought that that was the game. But Melbourne came back and got in front from a Ricky Pettard goal. Then a new Tiger attitude came and a kick to Jordan McMahon with 4 seconds to go (well actually it was in the air when the siren went, but the ump paid the mark and that's that) meant that he had to kick it in order for Richmond to win. And he did and boy did he need to do that! Still what a game and like Geelong Richond have played in two close games in a row!
To AAMI Stadium. And Port Adelaide hosted Hawthorn. This was kind of a see-sawing affair that eventually saw Port Adelaide to go out to a lead and stay there winning by 18 points. Well. What's going to happen to Hawthorn? They are now 10th on the ladder with four rounds to go! Can they make finals? Really they have to win all games for the rest of the year to give them a real chance. They have St Kilda at Aurora Stadium, then Adelaide at the MCG, Richmond at the MCG, and Essendon at the MCG. Now they could win all those games but I don't think that they can and may have to rely on others winning/losing in order for them to get in and believe you me they do not want to do that.
To the last game of the round that saw West Coast hosted Essendon at Subiaco. This was a game that a lot of people (including myself) thought that Essendon would win. But from the start West Coast controlled the game running away to win the game by 27 points. Obviously being sick of the tanking claims! Really I don't think clubs are tanking, maybe bad, but definately not tanking!
Catch ya!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)